Friday, August 7, 2009

Democratic Deliberation? Congressman David Scott's Town Hall Meltdown

This is a really mind-blogging report from WXIA-TV Atlanta, "Congressman Scott's Town Hall Meeting Meltdown":

U.S. Rep. David Scott (D-13th) was involved in what many called an embarrassing display of losing his temper at a town hall meeting in Douglasville last weekend.

In the meeting, Scott lost his temper and began yelling at a crowd that included two people who came forward during the question-and-answer portion of the meeting to ask Scott about his stance on the health care plan proposed by the White House and being debated on Capitol Hill.

The city of Douglasville taped the event and you can see Scott become increasingly agitated after a question about health care.

At one point he chastized some in the crowd for "hijacking" the meeting.

11Alive News has found the Douglas County doctor who posed one of the questions. Dr. Brian E. Hill, a urologist, said he simply wanted to know Congressman Scott's stance on government-provided insurance.

"I did not go to a meeting to create any problem. I simply have real questions about the quality of health care my patients are going to get not just now, but down the line," Hill said.
You know, the tea partyers have really been getting to the Democrats. The media-masters, party hacks, and lefty bloggesr have come up with every name in the book to smear and demonize regular citizens - and the vitriol is seeping into mainstream reporting, for example today, when CBS called citizen activists "teabaggers." And the Dems are arguing that all of a sudden democratic delibration is on the line when regular folks aren't getting their questions answered and they're getting mad. Democratic theory doesn't hold that flared tempers are undemocratic.

Just today, in
a widely-cited essay, Stephen Pearlstein argued:
Health reform is a test of whether this country can function once again as a civil society -- whether we can trust ourselves to embrace the big, important changes that require everyone to give up something in order to make everyone better off. Republican leaders are eager to see us fail that test.
That is teh stupid if there ever was any!

Why isn't President Obama reaching out to answer those who have legitimate questions, instead of making threats about gathering the names of those spreading "disinformation"? This administration is the utlimate in amateurish nighmare! This country is now way worse off under the Democrats - and considering the serious problems the GOP left the country, that's saying a lot.

This man at the clip, Brian Hill, a doctor, is exactly the kind of deliberative patriot all the Democrats keep idealizing as what's missing from the town hall rallies. And what does he get? A U.S. congressman pointing fingers and screaming at him for "hijacking" the meeting? Man, that's low. David Scott epitimizes not just what's wrong with the Dems, but what's wrong with the Democratic majority in Congress. Expect to see clips of him in upcoming debates, now and throughout 2010.

Democratic Party hypocrisy on democratic deliberation. Priceless.

I'm becoming increasingly convinced that Barack Obama shooting himself in the foot, and dooming himself to a one-term presidency. He'll be remembered as leaving one of the worst legacies of divisiveness in American history.

10 comments:

Steve Burri said...

I think many of those questioners were from DonaldDouglasville.

science fiction writer said...

That's one Democrat who is clearly "out of touch" with his constituents--but aren't they all?

Since when do the people serve the politicians: impeach this self-serving, angry, fraud.

Kevin Robbins said...

These jackasses disrupting town halls are as obnoxious as Code Pink squared. And how did that play out? They're not influencing anyone's opinion. They're just making any opposition to health care reform, even if it is legitimate, look like it's based on "if Obama is for it, we're against it." You know, sore losers from DonaldDouglasville.

Dennis said...

How dare those damn old people thinking they have a right to know what their representatives are thinking on healthcare. I mean they should just shut up and let themselves be denied service because we all know that they have no value to the society at large. That includes those lousy people with disabilities too. What the HELL good are they? These damn fools actually think they have a right to be heard! Gee you would think this is a free country or something. Who do these vile creatures think they are, Citizens?
Union thugs have a right to attack those damn dissenters because we all know that dissent is racist when it comes to this administration and anyone who would disagree is a Nazi orworse.
I have just put ex DLB's real thoughts into words.
Or as the new anthem for this country will soon be, "I am dictator Hear me roar. I don't need no stinking advice or consent from citizens anymore."

Dennis said...

I would not ever stop Code Pink, a group that I think is misguided, from demonstrating. Nor would i stop Nazi, a group I detest, from protesting. Ideas that are out in the open can be refuted with good argumentation. For those on the Left that means logic instead of name calling. NOTE: You can always tell when the Left lacks the ability to provide reasons for an idea because at the first sign of disagreement they go for the pejorative. A sure sign of weakness.
Once you force ideas underground they take on a life of their own and will become far more dangerous in the long run.
We do need to tweak Healthcare in this country, but we do not need government run healthcare. Once another person is paying your medical bills that person, read government, can dictate a large number of things in your life, including, food, drink, sports, et al. Almost anything that is done by a person can have healthcare possibilities and impacts.
Government always seeks more power. Show me a government that has given power back to the people on its own.

Dave said...

Thankfully, I don't live in David Scott's district (Tom Price is my rep) but I do drive through it on occasion.

The sad part is, he will probably be re-elected by a wide margin in November of 2010, with no small amount of help from the ObamACORNS and the ObamaThugs.

LOL-Sorry, didn't mean to be redundant there at the end.

-Dave

Dave said...

Ex DLB,

By that I assume you are referring to the lefty union goons who are showing up at town hall meetings and beating up black conservatives.

BTW, the RINOs are catching hell, too, in case you have missed it:

http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2009/08/08/gop-congressman-booed-telling-people-turn-glenn-beck

-Dave

Anonymous said...

Thanks for your blog. Keep up the great work.

Anonymous said...

About a week ago I was reading a Leftist-Liberal online newspaper called 'The Willamette Weekly'. On the right hand side of the page I was reading I noticed a paid for Ad. Here's what it said:
JOB!
BE A COMMUNITY ORGANIZER! HEALTH CARE REFORM NOW! INSPIRE SOCIAL 'CHANGE'! FIGHT FOR WORKING FAMILIES!
EARN $11 PER HOUR! FULL BENEFITS! RAPID ADVANCEMENT!
Call Now: (503)244-1004
WORKING AMERICA COMMUNITY Affiliate of the AFL-CIO
In the Flashing picture with the Ad, it showed women and men holding PRE-MADE signs that said:
DEMAND HEALTH CARE REFORM NOW!
WE NEED OBAMA's HEALTH CARE REFORM NOW!
Then, on Foxnews this morning I saw a picture of the PAID Protesters & the REAL Opponents, and there's NO QUESTION ABOUT IT, those hired and paid Pro-Genocidecare Protesters look COMPLETELY FAKE...So does Rep.David Scott...He is such a FAKE. He made himself look completely CLASSLESS and an IMBICILE! Yelling like a Woman like that. He looked CHEAP.
Tacky, tacky, trashy, and pathetic poor cry baby Rep.David Scott.
He KNOWS he's got half his butt OUT THE DOOR!
Time to Clean Up trash like Rep.Scott..Vote for Term Limits and clear out all the rubbish like him.

Unknown said...

In the Remaining Minutes, We’ll Take Questions on any Subject Err…Except That Subject.
The DNC keep pitching avoidance and deception, and let's hope the fiscal conservatives can keep pitching the spririted, but real issues in this government attempt to takeover 1/6th of the US economy.
Please check out my take, and stick around for more good content.
http://libertarianhumor.com/2009/08/10/obama-thugs-3/