It's not that big of a deal to me.
Photoshopping people for a dig is old hat, even for people on your own side. It's a little surprising, however, for such a big conservative brand as Red State to sink to petty locker room Photoshop humor as this. And
the post has been up for two days. Worse is that Erick Erickson defended the image as not Photoshopped when called out on Twitter, and
then some.
Folks contacted me privately after
I tweeted earlier.
Again, not that big a deal. That said, here's Jen Kuznicki, "
RedState misstates Palin and misses the point":
Anger erupted on twitter after RedState’s Peter List posted a photoshopped cleavage picture of Sarah Palin on his Diary, but the content of his post misstated her position, and shows how little he knows about the current fight going on in the GOP.
For all its buzz, RedState is a fairly static presence on the web. For instance, you can miss reading it for about 2 years, and then jump back in, and they are saying the same thing, with the same people, pointing out the same circumstance, and frankly, being really nasty and angry in the comment section.
List says that Palin’s third party solution is part of the problem. He knows she didn’t come up with a third party plan, and if he knows anything about boots-on-the-ground grassroots work, he would know that the third party idea is prevalent in the GOP rank and file. In his misleading post, List points to another RedState writer and how he has laid out the way to take over the GOP.
Is List ‘taking over’ the GOP? It seems to me that if you are going to preach it, you ought to do it. If he is in the fight, good, but I do not see the insight in his post that would prove such. For him, and his clique at RedState, I’ll lend a hand to show what has happened to warrant what many see as a possible alternative. And I’d like to stress the fact that Palin didn’t say she’s going third, she said, ‘if’ the current GOP establishment keeps on doing what they are doing, it certainly is a factor.
RTWT.
Jen's got a handle on the grumbles at the grassroots. Mostly, I just like how Erick Erickson gets a pass.
More on Twitter:
ADDED: This post has a lot of the details that I was unable to locate as I was writing this essay: "
RedState Posts Demeaning Photoshop of Governor Palin, Denies When Confronted — Updated."
Also, from Dan Riehl, "
Erickson and His Redstate Boys Never Learn, Titter at Faux Palin Ta-Ta’s." (Original photo there, compared to the Photoshop.)
Here's still more at C4P, "
RedState Boys Act Like Leftists When Confronted On Smears Against Governor Palin," and "
Redstate Posts Demeaning Photoshop of Governor Palin, Denies When Confronted — Updated."